Tuesday, January 26, 2016

Is Writing Considered Like Speech?

It says in Shemos [18/6] ויאמר אל משה אני חותנך יתרו בא אליך. He said to Moshe, I Yisro your "shver" am coming to you. 

In the Mechilta it says that he WROTE it in a letter. The Ramban learns this way as well. We see that even though the pasuk says that he "said", it means that he WROTE. 

There is a HUUUUGE argument if writing is considered as speaking - כתיבה כדיבור [FAMOUS FAMOUS teshuva of Rebbe Akiva Eiger]. 

What is the argument? We have an explicit pasuk here?